When a spreadsheet is fine
We make Resold, and we still think a spreadsheet is the right answer for many people. If you sell a handful of things, sit well under the reporting limits and are comfortable with formulas, it costs nothing and you control every column.
What matters to HMRC is that your records of income and expenses are complete. GOV.UK asks sole traders to keep records of business income and expenses(opens in a new tab), and to line them up with the tax year, 6 April to 5 April. A simple sheet with a row per sale does that.
- Date sold, platform and item
- Sold price, platform fee and postage you paid
- What you paid for the item, with the receipt saved somewhere you can find it
- Any other costs, such as packaging
Where spreadsheets struggle
- Fees differ by platform and change, so the formulas need checking. The free profit calculator does this sum for one sale.
- The reporting count is per platform. Your sheet needs a separate running total of sales and money for Vinted, Depop and eBay, against the 30 sale and about £1,700 (€2,000) limits.
- Entering sales on a phone, in a car park after a car boot, is fiddly.
- Receipts live in photos and carrier bags, not in the sheet.
- One wrong copy and paste can quietly change your totals.
Side by side
| Resold | Spreadsheet | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Free trial (7 days on yearly, 3 days on monthly), then £7.99 a month or £49.99 a year on the website | Free, plus your time |
| Fees and postage | Worked out per platform when you log a sale | You build and check the formulas |
| Reporting count | Live, per platform, against the limits | Only if you build it |
| £1,000 allowance | Tracked all year | Only if you build it |
| Receipts | Scan them and keep them with the item | Stored elsewhere |
| On your phone | Website and iPhone app | Fiddly on a small screen |
| Tax output | Tax Pack as PDF and CSV | Whatever you set up |
| Flexibility | Fixed layout | Total control. The spreadsheet wins |
Making Tax Digital and spreadsheets
Making Tax Digital for Income Tax began on 6 April 2026 for people with qualifying income over £50,000. It reaches £30,000 on 6 April 2027 and £20,000 on 6 April 2028. It applies to sole traders and landlords registered for Self Assessment whose qualifying income is over the threshold, so most casual resellers are nowhere near it. Check the dates on GOV.UK(opens in a new tab).
If it does apply, GOV.UK says you need commercial software that works with Making Tax Digital to keep digital records and send quarterly updates. A spreadsheet can only take part with bridging software, which connects to your spreadsheet and makes the submissions to HMRC.
Which should you choose?
Stay with a spreadsheet if
You sell a few things, have one platform and enjoy building your own system.
Try Resold if
You sell on more than one platform, want the reporting limits and allowance watched for you, or hate typing on a phone. There is a free trial (7 days on yearly, 3 days on monthly).
Talk to an accountant if
You are heading towards Making Tax Digital. Compare your options in our best reseller tax apps guide.
Official sources
Checked on 27 October 2026. Rules change, so always check the source.