Skip to content
Resold

Resold vs a spreadsheet

Resold vs a spreadsheet

A spreadsheet is free and flexible, but every sale, fee and receipt has to be typed in, and the 1099-K, tax estimate and Schedule C totals are yours to build. Resold does much of that for a subscription, so the better choice depends on how many sales you make and how much time you want to spend on records.

Check one sale in the profit calculator below, then use the table to decide. We make Resold, so we say where a spreadsheet wins.

Check your own figuresLast checked: November 9, 2026

Work out the real profit on one sale, which is the sum a spreadsheet makes you build and maintain yourself. Open the profit calculator on its own page.

Your sale

What did you actually make?

Pick a platform, fill in the sale and the result updates as you type. These are example figures, so replace them with yours.
Where did you sell it?

Your category may differ. Pick the closest.

eBay, Etsy, Depop and Facebook charge fees on it too

Boxes, mailers, tape

Type your actual fee to replace the estimate

Profit of $30.45. Platform fees $7.95. Margin 54.9 percent.

Your profit

After fees, shipping and costs, on a $48.00 sale on eBay.

  • Sale price$48.00
  • Shipping you charged$7.50
  • Minus platform fees (estimate)$7.95
  • Minus shipping you paid$7.50
  • Minus what you paid for the item$9.00
  • Minus supplies and other costs$0.60
  • Profit$30.45

Profit margin

54.9%

Profit as a share of what you were paid

Return on cost

317.2%

Profit as a share of the item and supplies

Fee estimate: $7.95

  • Final value fee$7.55
  • Per-order fee$0.40

13.6% final value fee up to $7,500 per item and 2.35% above, on the total amount of the sale (item, shipping and sales tax), plus $0.30 per order up to $10.00 or $0.40 above. Store subscribers pay less. Promoted Listings, international and other fees are extra. Presets last checked on November 9, 2026. Fees change and your category may differ, so check the platform's own page.

Source: ebay.com(opens in a new tab)Source: ebay.com(opens in a new tab)Source: ebay.com(opens in a new tab)

Track this automatically in Resold

Resold works this out for every sale you log, adds it up by month, and keeps the totals your tax return needs, with no spreadsheet.

Start your free trial

Up to 7 days free for new accounts, then from $8.99 a month. Cancel any time.

A spreadsheet and Resold at a glance

A spreadsheet compared with Resold
A spreadsheetResold
CostFree in a tool such as Google SheetsFree trial (7 days on yearly, 3 days on monthly), then $8.99 a month or $49.99 a year on the website (no free plan)
Getting sales inYou type each saleConnect eBay imports eBay sales; other marketplaces by hand, CSV import or forwarded sale emails
Fees and profitFormulas you write and keep currentShows real profit after platform fees and shipping
Item cost and inventoryA column or tab you designPer-item inventory and cost
ReceiptsPhotos and files stored separatelyReceipt scanning
1099-K totalsA running total per platform, built by youA meter per platform against the federal and state thresholds
Tax estimatesBrackets and self-employment tax formulas you buildSelf-employment and income tax estimates and quarterly reminders
Schedule C totalsA summary tab you buildSchedule C ready Tax Pack as PDF and CSV
FlexibilityAny column, any layoutFixed screens built for reselling

When a spreadsheet is enough

The IRS does not require a particular system. Topic no. 305(opens in a new tab) says to keep records that support the income and expenses you report, and a spreadsheet can do that. If you sell a modest number of items on one platform and like formulas, it costs nothing and you control every column.

  • Date sold, platform and item
  • Sale price, platform fees and shipping you paid
  • What you paid for the item, with the receipt saved somewhere you can find it
  • Supplies and other costs, with receipts

Our guide on tracking reselling income and expenses lists what to record, and you can use it with any tool.

Where a spreadsheet breaks

The pain points tend to arrive together. Here is how each looks in practice.

1099-K totals per platform. A platform files a Form 1099-K when your gross payments through it exceed $20,000 and the number of transactions exceeds 200 in a year, and some states use lower figures. The test is platform by platform. Say eBay paid you $14,200 over 260 transactions and Mercari $7,300 over 95. Your sheet total is $21,500 over 355 transactions, which looks over the line, but neither platform is over $20,000 on its own, so neither meets the federal test. A single total cannot tell you that, so you need a running count per platform. A form is also not the same as owing tax: the threshold only decides when a platform sends the form, and our 1099-K threshold guide explains more.

Tax math. Self-employment tax uses net earnings of 92.35% of your net profit. On a $5,000 net profit that is $5,000 x 0.9235 = $4,617.50. Social Security at 12.4% is $572.57, Medicare at 2.9% is $133.91, so self-employment tax is $706.48, and half of it, $353.24, is deductible on Schedule 1. Income tax depends on the rest of your return, and estimated tax is paid in four installments, so the sheet needs bracket tables and quarterly logic. You can check the sum with the free self-employment tax calculator.

Schedule C totals. At year end you need your sales, your cost of goods sold and your expenses grouped into the right categories. A mistyped category or a missing receipt quietly changes the total. See our Schedule C guide for what the form asks for.

What Resold does and does not do

  • Does: shows real profit after platform fees and shipping, keeps per-item inventory and cost, and scans receipts.
  • Does: keeps a 1099-K meter per platform against the federal and state thresholds.
  • Does: estimates self-employment and income tax, sends quarterly estimate reminders and builds a Schedule C ready Tax Pack as PDF and CSV.
  • Does: imports eBay sales automatically with Connect eBay. Other marketplaces are logged by hand, imported by CSV or added by forwarding sale emails.
  • Does not: file or e-file a return, connect to banks, or connect to Poshmark, Mercari, Depop, Whatnot, Etsy or Facebook accounts.
  • Does not: replace a tax professional. It prepares records and estimates.

Moving between a spreadsheet and Resold

Resold imports sales from a CSV file, so a spreadsheet you already keep can be exported as CSV and brought in. Resold also exports all your data, and the Tax Pack, as PDF and CSV, so your records are not locked in.

Price

A spreadsheet costs nothing in a free tool. Resold's website price, as of November 9, 2026, is a free trial (7 days on yearly, 3 days on monthly), then $8.99 a month or $49.99 a year, with no free plan. Twelve months at $8.99 is $107.88, so the yearly price is $57.89 less. Whether that is worth it depends on the hours you spend on records, and we have no measured figure for that, so we will not invent one.

Our bias, and how to choose

  1. Stay with a spreadsheet if

    You sell on one platform, the totals are small, and you enjoy building and checking formulas.

  2. Try Resold if

    You sell on several platforms, you skip entering fees, costs or receipts, or you want per-platform 1099-K totals and a tax estimate without building them.

  3. Either way

    Keep a record for every sale and every receipt. See also how the best apps for reseller taxes compare.

Sources

Last checked: November 9, 2026. Rules change, so always check the source.

FAQ

Common questions

  • It can be. The IRS lets you choose any recordkeeping system that clearly shows your income and expenses and keep records that support what you report. The work is on you: entering each sale, fee and receipt, and building the totals your return needs.

  • Yes. Resold exports all your data, and the Tax Pack, as PDF and CSV.

  • No. Resold prepares records, estimates and a Schedule C ready Tax Pack. It does not file or e-file a return and it does not give tax advice. A tax professional can still review your records and prepare your return.

  • It depends on how many sales you make and how you keep records now, and we have no measured figure to quote. The time an app saves is mostly typing fees and costs, scanning receipts and building totals. If you sell only a few items, the saving is small.

  • Yes. Resold imports sales from a CSV file, so you can export a spreadsheet as CSV and bring your sales in.

Track this automatically in Resold

Resold does the fee math, keeps a 1099-K meter per platform and builds a Schedule C ready Tax Pack, so you can leave the formulas behind. Try it free for up to 7 days.

Start your free trial

Up to 7 days free for new accounts, then from $8.99 a month. Cancel any time.

More free tools

Resold is not affiliated with the IRS, eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, Depop, Whatnot, Etsy or Meta.

Not tax advice. Check IRS.gov or a tax professional.