Sole proprietor versus LLC
If you sell regularly and have not formed a company, you are generally a sole proprietor for tax purposes. You report on Schedule C and pay income tax and self-employment tax on the profit. A limited liability company is a legal structure created under state law. The two are not opposites.
| Topic | Sole proprietor | LLC |
|---|---|---|
| Starting | Usually no state filing. A trade name may need registering | File with your state and pay its fee |
| Federal tax reporting | Schedule C | A single-member LLC generally reports the same way |
| Self-employment tax | Yes, if net earnings reach $400 | Generally the same for a single-member LLC |
| Personal liability | Your personal assets can be reachable | May separate business and personal debts, if kept up properly |
| Ongoing cost | None from the structure | State fees and reports, which vary |
What an LLC changes and what it does not
A single-member LLC is generally treated as a sole proprietorship for federal income tax unless it elects otherwise, so it does not usually lower your tax by itself. Publication 334(opens in a new tab) explains how businesses are structured for tax purposes. Your profit, your 92.35% factor and the 15.3% self-employment tax stay the same. Other tax elections exist. Ask a tax professional before assuming they help a small reseller.
It also does not replace the basics. You still need to track income and costs, report your profit and pay any estimated taxes. Platform forms such as the 1099-K may be issued to you or to your LLC depending on how your payout account is set up, so keep the names and tax IDs on your accounts consistent. The 1099-K guide explains when a form arrives.
What an LLC can do is separate your business debts from your personal assets. Whether that is worth the cost depends on your risks, such as what you sell and who you deal with. That is a legal question, and this guide is not legal advice.
Seller's permits and local licenses
Licenses and permits come from your state, county and city, not from the IRS. They may include a general business license, a sales tax permit (called a seller's permit or sales tax license in some states) and local rules for working from home. Requirements differ widely, and some places ask little of a casual seller.
The Small Business Administration has a page on applying for licenses and permits(opens in a new tab) that explains the types and links to your state. Start with your state revenue department and your city or county clerk. Marketplaces set their own seller rules, so read each platform's terms too.
Resale certificates
A resale certificate lets a registered seller buy inventory from a supplier without paying sales tax, because tax is collected when the item is resold. It generally requires a state registration such as a seller's permit, and the rules depend on the state. Casual sourcing from thrift stores or garage sales usually does not involve one. The sales tax guide explains who collects what.
EIN basics
An employer identification number is a federal tax ID. A sole proprietor with no employees may not need one, since many use their Social Security number, and Schedule C asks for an EIN only if you have one. You may need an EIN if you hire employees or file certain returns, and an LLC with more than one member generally does. The Schedule C instructions(opens in a new tab) and Publication 334 explain this.
When to talk to a professional
- You sell items that carry safety, legal or insurance risk
- You plan to hire help, rent a space or sign contracts
- You have a partner or co-owner
- You are unsure what your state or city requires
A state small business office, an attorney or a CPA can answer these for your location.
Next steps
Decide hobby or business
Read the hobby or business guide. The answer affects your tax more than a structure does.
Check your state and city
Use the SBA page above, then your state revenue department and local clerk.
Know your sales tax position
Read the sales tax guide before you sell in person.
Keep clean records
Records matter whether or not you form an LLC.
Sources
Last checked: November 9, 2026. Rules change, so always check the source.