What the IRS says
The IRS has a hobby or business page(opens in a new tab) for people with a side hustle. It asks whether you carry on the activity to make a profit, whether you work at it regularly and whether you depend on the income. There is no minimum number of sales and no single test that decides it.
The legal test comes from Treasury Regulation 1.183-2(opens in a new tab). It looks at all the facts and circumstances, and it says no one factor is decisive.
The factors, in plain English
The regulation lists nine factors. The IRS tax tip page lists fewer, but the regulation is the source. Here they are in plain words.
- How you run it: do you keep complete and accurate books and records, and act like a business?
- Your expertise: do you, or advisors you rely on, know the market you sell in?
- Time and effort: how much time do you put in, and is it regular?
- Asset value: do you expect the things you hold to rise in value?
- Your track record: have you made a success of other activities, similar or not?
- Your history: has this activity made profits or losses over the years?
- Occasional profits: how large are the profits when you do make one?
- Your finances: do you depend on this income, or do you have plenty of other income?
- Personal enjoyment: is it mainly something you do for fun, or for the money?
Enjoying it does not make it a hobby. Many resellers like thrifting and still run a business. The question is how you operate.
Hobby versus business
| Topic | Hobby | Business |
|---|---|---|
| Is the income taxable? | Yes | Yes |
| Where it is reported | Schedule 1, as other income | Schedule C |
| Self-employment tax | No | Yes, if net earnings reach $400 |
| Expenses | Not deductible under current law | Ordinary and necessary costs are generally deductible |
| A loss | A hobby cannot produce a deductible loss | A loss can be reported on Schedule C |
Three examples
Closet clean-out. You sell a dozen things you own and no longer wear, for less than you paid. That is not a business, and it is not reported on Schedule C. The loss on a personal item is not deductible. A gain on a personal item may be taxable. See the loss guide.
Weekly thrift flipping. You shop most weekends, buy to resell, list on two platforms and keep a spreadsheet. That points toward a business. Suppose you earn $3,000 and spend $800 on supplies, software and mileage. As a business, you report $2,200 of profit and pay about $311 of self-employment tax on it ($2,200 x 0.9235 = $2,031.70, times 15.3%). As a hobby, you would report $3,000 with no deduction for the $800 and no self-employment tax.
Full time. Reselling is your main income, you sell most days and you carry stock. That generally points to a business, with self-employment tax and likely quarterly payments.
The profit test in brief
Under Internal Revenue Code section 183(d), an activity is presumed to be for profit if it made a profit in at least 3 of the last 5 years. It is not a requirement, and a new business can lose money while the IRS still treats it as a business. It is a rule of thumb that shifts the burden when you meet it.
If you are early in an activity, Form 5213 can postpone the determination. A tax professional can tell you whether that election suits you. The statute is on the Cornell Legal Information Institute site(opens in a new tab).
If you are unsure
Write down how you operate
How often you sell, how you source, whether you track cost and profit, and how much time it takes.
Keep records either way
Good books are the first factor in the list and the thing most likely to help if you are asked.
Separate personal and resale items
Keep a clear line between a clean-out and items bought to resell.
Ask a professional
If a lot rides on the answer, a CPA or enrolled agent can look at your facts.
Sources
Last checked: November 9, 2026. Rules change, so always check the source.
- IRS: Hobby or business, what to know about that side hustle(opens in a new tab)
- IRS: Instructions for Schedule C(opens in a new tab)
- IRS: Publication 535, Business Expenses(opens in a new tab)
- Treasury Regulation 1.183-2: Activity not engaged in for profit(opens in a new tab)
- 26 U.S.C. 183: Activities not engaged in for profit(opens in a new tab)